Rich Hickey argues that Large Language Models (LLMs) are not tools in the traditional sense, but rather a form of automation. He distinguishes tools as implements that are wielded with control, intention, and continuous direction, requiring expertise and providing feedback. In contrast, LLMs operate autonomously, responding to requests without direct human manipulation or the development of skill. Hickey contends that using LLMs to avoid tasks like writing code or summarizing research means abdicating the learning process and instead engaging in a cycle of AI
IMPACT Challenges the common framing of LLMs as tools, suggesting a shift in understanding their role and impact on skill development.
RANK_REASON Opinion piece by a known figure in software development.
Read on Hacker News — AI stories ≥50 points →
AI-generated summary · Google Gemini · from 1 sources. How we write summaries →
